Let me pull up data on both archetypes simultaneously!
Let me try some alternate names for these archetypes:
The "Persist" result is for Duel Commander. Let me search more broadly in Modern for these archetypes:
I can see Grixis Graveyard and Grixis Reanimator as the likely candidates. Let me pull overviews on both, plus check the Goryo Reanimator archetype:
I can see Goryo Reanimator is likely "Grixis Goryo's" and Grixis Reanimator is likely "Grixis Persist." Let me verify by checking their key cards more deeply, and also fetch winrates for a proper comparison:
Now I have everything I need. Let me also grab trend data and sources:
Great, I now have a comprehensive picture of both archetypes. Here's the full comparison:
ℹ️ In the database: "Goryo Reanimator" = Grixis Goryo's | "Grixis Reanimator" = Grixis Persist
| Stat | Goryo Reanimator | Grixis Persist |
|---|---|---|
| Tournament Entries | 2,883 (49 events) | 650 (47 events) |
| Winrate (excl. mirror) | 51.96% | 52.26% |
| Wins / Losses / Draws | 465W / 430L / 31D | 301W / 275L / 8D |
| Total Matches | 926 | 584 |
Both decks are nearly neck-and-neck in winrate, but Goryo's has ~4.4x more meta presence — it's clearly the more popular choice.
Goryo Reanimator (the Goryo's shell):
Grixis Persist (the Persist shell):
Sources: Data from 148 Modern tournaments (62% MTGO, 38% Melee)