I'll analyze the performance of Amulet Titan decks with different combinations of Icetill Explorer and Urza's Cave in the maindeck. Let me start by getting the current Modern format data and then examine these specific configurations.
Now let me search for the specific cards to get their card IDs:
Now I'll use a custom query to analyze the performance of Amulet Titan decks with these different card combinations:
Let me get some sources for this analysis:
Based on my analysis of Amulet Titan performance in Modern since August 2025, the data shows clear performance differences between the four configurations:
Best performing: Both Icetill Explorer and Urza's Cave maindeck - 60.0% winrate (32 entries, 93-62 record). This configuration significantly outperformed all others, suggesting strong synergy between the two cards in the current meta.
Second best: Neither card - 55.4% winrate (53 entries, 144-116 record). Traditional builds without either card still performed well, indicating the core Amulet Titan strategy remains solid.
Third: Urza's Cave only - 51.0% winrate (133 entries, 293-282 record). This was the most common configuration but showed mediocre results, suggesting Cave alone doesn't provide significant advantage.
Worst: Icetill Explorer only - 33.3% winrate (3 entries, 3-6 record). Very small sample size, but the poor performance suggests Icetill without Cave support may not be optimal.
The data indicates that when playing these newer cards, running both together provides the best results, likely due to Icetill's graveyard synergy working well with Cave's sacrifice ability.
Sources
Data from 86 tournaments: 82.6% MTGO, 17.4% Melee. Recent tournaments include:
https://www.mtgo.com/decklist/modern-challenge-64-2025-09-2912816562
https://www.mtgo.com/decklist/modern-challenge-32-2025-09-2912816558
https://melee.gg/Decklist/View/91a51e51-fc70-4ad1-ad8e-b366001afdd7