I'll pull data on both questions simultaneously — Eldrazi matchups and the Dimir archetype comparison in Modern.
Interesting — the results show that Eldrazi, Dimir Tempo, and Dimir Midrange are each living in different formats. Let me clarify and pull the right data. The meta report I already have is for Modern, where "Ramp Eldrazi" is the relevant Eldrazi archetype. For the Dimir question, I need to check both Modern and Legacy, and find the right archetypes. Let me now pull Eldrazi matchups against Modern's top decks, and also dig deeper on the Dimir archetypes.
Good — Ramp Eldrazi is the Modern version. Now let me pull all the matchups for Ramp Eldrazi vs the top 8 Modern decks simultaneously, and also search for Dimir archetypes in Modern more broadly.
No Dimir Tempo in Modern — there are several Dimir variants though. Let me now get the card lists for Dimir Midrange and the most promising "tempo-like" Dimir variants (Dimir Frog, Dimir Shadow) in Modern to compare them, and grab sources.
I have all the data I need. Note that "Dimir Midrange" in Modern has essentially no presence (only 2 matches), while "Dimir Frog" is the main Dimir archetype in Modern. The question about Dimir Tempo vs Dimir Midrange most likely refers to Legacy (where both exist and have substantial data). Let me compile everything now.
Here is the full breakdown, @JurgenKowalsky:
RAMP ELDRAZI MATCHUP WINRATES vs TOP MODERN DECKS (Apr 15 - Jun 15 2026)
Ramp Eldrazi sits at a 50.4% overall winrate across 3,616 entries. Its matchup profile is quite polarized:
Favorable matchups (Eldrazi wins):
Even/close matchups:
Unfavorable matchups (Eldrazi loses):
The pattern is clear: Eldrazi preys on fast aggro/combo (Prowess, Goryo, Amulet) but struggles hard against permission-based control (Azorius) and graveyard strategies that can go bigger (Grixis Reanimator). The Boros Energy and Affinity matchups are near coin-flip but slightly unfavorable, which is notable given those are the two most-played decks in the format at 12.5% and 9.1% presence respectively.
DIMIR TEMPO VS DIMIR MIDRANGE (in Modern)
In Modern, "Dimir Midrange" as a standalone archetype is essentially nonexistent right now (only 2 matches recorded). The relevant Dimir variants are Dimir Frog (the dominant one, ~91 entries in the window) and Dimir Shadow, Dimir Scam, etc. as smaller fringe strategies. Dimir Frog is likely what players mean by "Dimir Tempo" in Modern: it runs Psychic Frog, Orcish Bowmasters, Thoughtseize, Counterspell, Force of Negation, and Spell Snare — a tempo-oriented gameplan of cheap disruption + growing threats.
If you're asking about Legacy, both archetypes are alive and well. Dimir Tempo (2,080 entries, 51.9% winrate) is defined by Brainstorm, Force of Will, Ponder, Flow State, and Thoughtseize — it plays a classic Legacy tempo shell of cantrips + counterspells + discard. Key cards like Undercity Sewers and Fatal Push round out the interaction suite. Dimir Midrange doesn't have a comparable presence in the Legacy data, suggesting the term may be used interchangeably or the Tempo build has absorbed that label.
In short: in Modern, "Dimir tempo" = Dimir Frog (47.5% winrate, slightly underperforming). In Legacy, Dimir Tempo is a well-established archetype with over 51% winrate across thousands of entries.
Sources: Data from 148 Modern tournaments (Apr 15 - Jun 15 2026), split 62% MTGO / 38% Melee.