Let me pull up the Mono Green Broodscale archetype and check its key matchup data across the relevant formats.
Let me try some alternate names and search for the key card:
Good, found it in Modern. Now let me get matchup data against the top archetypes in the current meta:
Now let me check Broodscale's matchups against the top meta decks simultaneously:
Here is the breakdown of Broodscale's worst matchups in Modern over the last two months (July 8 - September 7, 2026), based on 438 entries across 121 tournaments:
The clearest bad matchup is Esper Blink, where Broodscale sits at just 43.5% (50W-65L). Esper Blink's suite of interaction, blink-based value, and disruption appears to grind through what Broodscale is trying to do effectively. Boros Energy is another losing matchup at 47.5% (58W-64L), likely due to its speed and pressure. Goryo Reanimator (49.1%) and Prowess (49.5%) are essentially coin-flips where Broodscale has a marginal negative edge - both are faster combo-adjacent strategies that can race or disrupt the setup.
On the flip side, Broodscale actually has strong edges against Affinity (65.0%) and Tron (63.2%), so not everything is bad news. The deck sits at a healthy 52.4% overall winrate, making it a solid meta choice despite those trouble spots.
Sources: Data from 140 Modern tournaments (78.6% MTGO, 21.4% Melee). Recent events include:
https://melee.gg/Decklist/View/a092160b-24cc-4dec-8d1e-b4bd00fd91f6
https://melee.gg/Decklist/View/8c0b50e9-8c44-4d74-afbf-b4bd00ea2461
https://www.mtgo.com/decklist/modern-challenge-64-2026-09-0612853698