I'll analyze the best performing decks across all formats and their head-to-head matchups. Let me gather the data for each format.
Now let me get the head-to-head matchups for each format:
Best Deck: Boros Energy (14.0% presence, 49.8% winrate)
Second Best: Domain Zoo (7.1% presence, 49.8% winrate)
Head-to-Head: Boros Energy vs Domain Zoo - 51.3% (81-77 record)
Best Deck: Dimir Reanimator (17.8% presence, 58.4% winrate)
Second Best: Mono Red Prison (7.2% presence, 54.7% winrate)
Head-to-Head: Dimir Reanimator vs Mono Red Prison - 44.2% (46-58 record)
Best Deck: Madness (13.2% presence, 49.7% winrate)
Second Best: Mono Blue Delver (9.3% presence, 55.4% winrate)
Head-to-Head: Madness vs Mono Blue Delver - 38.4% (33-53 record)
Best Deck: Mono Red Aggro (25.5% presence, 50.2% winrate)
Second Best: Rakdos Demons (11.2% presence, 50.9% winrate)
Head-to-Head: Mono Red Aggro vs Rakdos Demons - 48.9% (110-115 record)
Best Deck: Izzet Cauldron (20.0% presence, 55.1% winrate)
Second Best: Dimir Midrange (18.0% presence, 51.0% winrate)
Head-to-Head: Izzet Cauldron vs Dimir Midrange - 52.7% (224-201 record)
Best Deck: Esper Lurrus Control (10.5% presence, 55.4% winrate)
Second Best: Initiative (10.1% presence, 44.4% winrate)
Head-to-Head: Esper Lurrus Control vs Initiative - 53.6% (15-13 record)
Key Insights:
• Legacy has the highest winrate spread (58.4% vs 44.4%)
• Pioneer shows the most balanced top-tier matchup (48.9%)
• Pauper's "best" deck by presence actually loses to the second-best deck
• Standard and Vintage show favorable matchups for the #1 deck
Sources: Data from 103 Modern tournaments (83.5% MTGO, 16.5% Melee) and similar coverage across other formats. Recent examples: Modern Challenge 32, Modern Challenge 64.
Here are all the available formats in the database:
Total: 6 formats tracked in the database.
These format IDs can be used with other analysis tools to get meta reports, archetype data, card presence, and tournament results for each specific format.