← Back to Sessions

Broodscales Matchup Breakdown Top 10 Decks

1 requestsStarted 3/14/2026, 12:56:52 AM
What are Broodscales win rates against the top 10 decks?

Let me gather the data needed for this analysis!

🛠️Get Meta Report

Now let me fetch all 10 matchups simultaneously. Broodscale itself appears in the meta report (I'll exclude it), and I'll get matchups vs all top 10 archetypes.

Here is Broodscale's matchup breakdown vs the Modern top 10 over the last ~2 months (Jan 9 - Mar 11, 2026), overall winrate 51.7%:

FAVORABLE MATCHUPS

  • vs Affinity: 86.4% (19-3, 22 matches) -- dominant
  • vs Domain Zoo: 75.0% (15-5, 20 matches)
  • vs Amulet Titan: 68.8% (11-5, 16 matches)
  • vs Jeskai Blink: 58.1% (18-13, 31 matches)
  • vs Boros Energy: 56.9% (29-22, 51 matches)

EVEN/CONTESTED

  • vs Azorius Control: 50.0% (2-2, only 4 matches -- low sample, treat with caution)
  • vs Ramp Eldrazi: 47.1% (8-9, 17 decisive)
  • vs Tron: 44.4% (12-15, 27 matches)

UNFAVORABLE MATCHUPS

  • vs Ruby Storm: 41.7% (10-14, 24 matches)
  • vs Prowess: 20.0% (3-12, 15 matches) -- very rough

The standout story is the Affinity blowout -- an 86% winrate is nearly unheard of at this scale. Prowess is the mirror-image problem at just 20%; the go-wide, redundant-threat style that Prowess runs appears to punish Broodscale hard. Ruby Storm is the other notable threat, likely because it can combo off faster than Broodscale can establish its engine. Note that several matchups (Azorius Control, Prowess, Amulet Titan) have smaller sample sizes under 20 matches, so treat those numbers as directional rather than definitive.

Sources: Data from 72 tournaments (64% MTGO, 36% Melee) since Jan 9, 2026.