Good, I have all four archetype IDs. Now let me pull the meta report to find the top Modern archetypes, then run matchup winrates against all four targets simultaneously.
Now let me run all the matchup winrates simultaneously for the top archetypes against all four targets:
Here is a full breakdown of which Modern archetypes post positive winrates (>50%) against all four targets — Tron, Yawgmoth, Azorius Control, and Amulet Titan — over the past two months (Feb 6 - Apr 7, 2026). Note: matchups with fewer than ~10 games should be treated with caution.
NO ARCHETYPE IN THE TOP 20 SWEEPS ALL FOUR MATCHUPS. Here is how the closest candidates break down:
AFFINITY (53.8% overall WR, 6th in meta)
vs Tron: 55.7% (70 matches)
vs Yawgmoth: 77.8% (27 matches) — dominant
vs Azorius Control: 50.0% (40 matches) — exactly even
vs Amulet Titan: 37.3% (51 matches) — loses badly
Miss: Amulet Titan
BOROS ENERGY (51.4% overall WR, #1 in meta)
vs Tron: 55.4% (215 matches)
vs Yawgmoth: 43.8% (32 matches) — loses
vs Azorius Control: 60.4% (101 matches)
vs Amulet Titan: 40.5% (178 matches) — loses badly
Miss: Yawgmoth + Amulet Titan
GRIXIS CONTROL (56.9% overall WR)
vs Tron: 76.5% (17 matches)
vs Yawgmoth: 0.0% (1 match) — no data
vs Azorius Control: 90.0% (10 matches)
vs Amulet Titan: 73.9% (23 matches) — exceptional
Miss: Yawgmoth sample is too small to evaluate (1 match)
SIMIC RITUAL (53.4% overall WR)
vs Tron: 72.7% (22 matches)
vs Yawgmoth: 16.7% (6 matches) — terrible
vs Azorius Control: 75.0% (8 matches)
vs Amulet Titan: 83.3% (18 matches) — dominant
Miss: Yawgmoth — severely loses
BLUE BELCHER (54.5% overall WR)
vs Tron: 63.6% (22 matches)
vs Yawgmoth: 66.7% (9 matches)
vs Azorius Control: 50.0% (10 matches) — even
vs Amulet Titan: 50.0% (16 matches) — even
Closest to sweeping all four with at least 50%+ in every matchup, though AzCtrl and Titan are exactly 50/50. Sample sizes on the smaller side.
DOMAIN ZOO (49.8% overall WR)
vs Tron: 48.5% (33 matches) — loses slightly
vs Yawgmoth: 50.0% (10 matches) — even
vs Azorius Control: 64.3% (14 matches)
vs Amulet Titan: 51.4% (37 matches) — slight edge
Miss: Tron
The honest answer is: no archetype cleanly posts >50% into all four simultaneously based on current data. Blue Belcher comes closest — positive or 50/50 into all four — and Grixis Control looks very promising into three of them (Tron 76.5%, AzCtrl 90%, Titan 73.9%) but has near-zero Yawgmoth data. If you specifically need to beat Yawgmoth AND the other three, the data points most strongly toward Blue Belcher as the best compromise pick.
Sources: Data from 144 Modern tournaments Feb 6 – Apr 7, 2026 (70.8% MTGO, 29.2% Melee).
https://www.mtgo.com/decklist/modern-challenge-64-2026-04-0412838129
https://www.mtgo.com/decklist/modern-challenge-32-2026-04-0412838136
https://www.mtgo.com/decklist/modern-challenge-32-2026-04-0512838140