That's a detailed request! Let me start by gathering the data I need — first I'll look up the Broodscale archetype and search for Dismember simultaneously.
Got both IDs. Now let me fetch all entries for the Broodscale archetype over the last 6 weeks so I can split them by Dismember presence and then compute matchup winrates per opponent archetype.
The wins/losses/draws are all 0 — it looks like the result field on the matches table may be stored differently (e.g., on the entry side rather than per-match). Let me check the actual schema to fix the query.
Results use WIN/LOSS/DRAW — fixing the query now with the correct values and proper date filtering on matches via the tournament join.
Now let me get the sources for citation.
Here's the full MU-by-MU breakdown. I've filtered to matchups with ≥10 non-mirror matches for statistical relevance. Entries: 666 w/ Dismember vs 166 without.
Format: W% (W-L) | Min. 10 matches per group
| Matchup | 🗡️ w/ Dismember | ❌ w/o Dismember | Δ |
|---|---|---|---|
| Prowess | 51.8% (192-179) | 55.8% (53-42) | -4.0 |
| Esper Blink | 52.6% (160-144) | 51.9% (28-26) | +0.7 |
| Goryo Reanimator | 58.9% (166-116) | 45.2% (38-46) | +13.7 ✅ |
| Affinity | 63.4% (137-79) | 62.8% (27-16) | +0.6 |
| Devoted Combo | 43.0% (71-94) | 36.6% (15-26) | +6.4 ✅ |
| Tron | 62.6% (92-55) | 53.8% (21-18) | +8.8 ✅ |
| Boros Energy | 48.1% (64-69) | 50.0% (12-12) | -1.9 |
| Boros Ponza | 69.3% (79-35) | 40.9% (9-13) | +28.4 ✅ |
| Ruby Storm | 49.6% (59-60) | 57.1% (12-9) | -7.5 |
| Dimir Frog | 65.0% (76-41) | 48.5% (16-17) | +16.5 ✅ |
| Fight Rigging Eldrazi | 52.8% (57-51) | 37.9% (11-18) | +14.9 ✅ |
| Domain Zoo | 48.5% (49-52) | 68.4% (13-6) | -19.9 ❌ |
| Living End | 64.7% (55-30) | 65.6% (21-11) | -0.9 |
| Neobrand | 45.9% (39-46) | 50.0% (11-11) | -4.1 |
| AZ Control | 58.7% (44-31) | 50.0% (10-10) | +8.7 ✅ |
| Amulet Titan | 50.0% (33-33) | 47.4% (9-10) | +2.6 |
| Jeskai Energy | 43.1% (22-29) | 27.3% (3-8) | +15.8 ✅ |
| Dimir Control | 81.6% (31-7) | — | — |
| Azorius Loki | 43.3% (13-17) | — | — |
| Boros Ponza | 69.3% | 40.9% | +28.4 |
| Simic Ritual | 76.9% (20-6) | — | — |
| Grixis Reanimator | 61.5% (16-10) | 72.7% (8-3) | -11.2 |
| Hollow One | 47.4% (18-20) | 36.4% (4-7) | +11.0 ✅ |
| Yawgmoth | 60.0% (12-8) | — | — |
Dismember clearly helps vs:
Dismember may hurt vs (small samples, caution):
Largely neutral:
⚠️ Note: The "w/o Dismember" group is much smaller (166 entries vs 666), so matchups with low counts for that group should be interpreted cautiously.
Sources: 120 tournaments (Aug 3 – Sep 14, 2026) | 60% MTGO / 40% Melee