I'll start by resolving the archetype and both cards simultaneously.
Good, cards found. Now let me search for the correct archetype name, and also look up related variants (Emry, Tamiyo steel-cutter archetypes):
Let me search the database directly to find archetypes containing the Steelcutter card or Emry/Tamiyo in Modern:
SQLite uses LIKE not ILIKE. Let me fix that and also search for archetypes containing Cori-Steel Cutter:
The primary Cori-Steel Cutter archetype is "izzet cutter" (ID: 431308f7). The user wants all cutter variants including Emry, Tamiyo variants. Let me check which of these archetypes contain Emry/Tamiyo, and also confirm the Quantum Riddler and Erayo card IDs. Now I'll run the core winrate queries:
Now I have all the archetype IDs. The "cutter" archetypes with Emry/Tamiyo are: izzet cutter (431308f7), jeskai cutter (9ca33ec5), temur cutter (5b8c466c), wurg cutter (02a84500), wubr cutter (cebbb13a). Let me now run the main analysis queries for Quantum Riddler vs Erayo, and Minamo splits:
The CTE queries are being blocked — let me rewrite these as flat subquery-based SELECTs:
I see that match results are all 0 wins/losses — the result field may use different values. Let me check the match result values:
Results use 'WIN'/'LOSS'/'DRAW' — let me rerun all the winrate queries with the correct values, and also add the Minamo splits:
All data collected. Now let me get sources to cite:
Here are the results, @3emeFarceur:
Quantum Riddler vs Erayo — all Modern Cutter variants (Oct 2025 – Apr 2026)
Scope: Izzet Cutter, Jeskai Cutter, Temur Cutter, WURG Cutter, WUBR Cutter — mirrors excluded.
The gap slightly favors Erayo, but the sample is very lopsided — Erayo shows up in only 7 entries versus 200 for Riddler, so those 46 matches are a very thin basis. The Erayo number should be treated as anecdotal rather than statistically conclusive.
Minamo split — across ALL cutter variants combined (Oct 2025 – Apr 2026)
(This covers entries with OR without Riddler/Erayo, mirrors excluded)
The Minamo edge is real but modest, and it comes from a reasonable sample (183 matches across the land-running builds). Given that Minamo is typically a 1-of utility land, this slight performance uplift is consistent with its role as a marginal quality-of-life include rather than a core engine piece.
Sources: 140 tournaments tracked (Oct 2025 – Apr 2026), 65.7% MTGO / 34.3% Melee.