โ† Back to Sessions

Ruby Storm vs Broodscale for Modern RCQ

1 requestsStarted 5/4/2026, 6:25:11 PM
in an rcq event for modern would be a good choice to pick a deck like ruby storm or broodscale combo?

Let me pull up data on both archetypes simultaneously!

Interesting โ€” both archetypes are showing up as Pauper in the database, not Modern. Let me search for their Modern-specific versions!

๐Ÿ› ๏ธGet Meta Report

Now I have solid Modern data. Let me grab trend and winrate details for both decks in the Modern format!

๐Ÿ› ๏ธGet Archetype Trends
๐Ÿ› ๏ธGet Archetype Trends
๐Ÿ› ๏ธGet Tournament Results

Here's a data-backed comparison for your RCQ decision:


โšก Ruby Storm vs ๐Ÿ› Broodscale Combo โ€” Modern RCQ Pick

(Last 60 days, 2026-02-25 โ†’ 2026-04-27)

๐Ÿ“Š Meta Presence & Performance

StatRuby StormBroodscale
Meta Presence5.18% (#6)1.31% (#20)
Overall Winrate47.3% โŒ51.5% โœ…
Top 8 Share5.0%1.4%
Entries (60d)19048

๐Ÿ“‰ Weekly Trend Highlights

Ruby Storm has been declining in both presence and performance:

  • Early March peaked at ~8% presence
  • Winrates have been volatile: 30% โ†’ 47% โ†’ 58% โ†’ then crashing back down recently
  • Clearly meta-dependent and inconsistent week to week

Broodscale is a low-volume deck with very swingy results:

  • Had a great week Apr 13-19 (77.8% WR!) but tiny sample (10 entries)
  • Other weeks show 0โ€“43% WR โ€” extremely volatile
  • Very low representation makes it hard to read as a reliable choice

๐Ÿ† RCQ Verdict

Neither deck looks like a slam-dunk pick for an RCQ right now:

  • Ruby Storm has more reps and top 8 appearances, but its 47.3% overall winrate is below 50% โ€” meaning it's losing more than it wins on average. In a high-stakes single elimination or modified Swiss event, that's concerning.
  • Broodscale shows flashes of brilliance but is too low-volume and inconsistent to reliably trust for an RCQ.

๐Ÿ”Ž If you're looking at combo in Modern RCQs, the data suggests checking out Amulet Titan (55.2% WR), Blue Belcher (57% WR), or Simic Ritual (54% WR) as combo/ramp options performing significantly better.


๐Ÿ“Œ Sources: Data from 106 tournaments (84% MTGO, 16% Melee).
Recent events: Modern Challenge 32 (Apr 26) ยท Modern Challenge 32 (Apr 25) ยท Modern Challenge 32 (Apr 19)