Broodscale's 10 Worst Modern Matchups

Here are Broodscale's 10 worst matchups in Modern (last ~60 days, min. 15 matches, mirrors excluded):

#	Opponent	W	L	D	WR%
1	Grixis Frog	8	12	1	40.0%
2	Jeskai Energy	25	37	0	40.3%
3	Devoted Combo	90	123	4	42.3%
4	Azorius Loki	14	18	2	43.8%
5	Esper Frog	7	9	0	43.8%
6	Amulet Titan	55	69	1	44.4%
7	Hollow One	23	27	1	46.0%
8	Esper Scam	6	7	2	46.2%
9	Neobrand	63	70	1	47.4%
10	Boros Energy	105	116	4	47.5%

Key takeaways:

Grixis/Esper Frog variants are Broodscale's hardest matchups — the interactive, value-based Frog decks seem to grind it out effectively
Jeskai Energy is a significant problem at 40.3% across a large sample (62 matches)
Devoted Combo is the highest-volume bad matchup (217 matches, 42.3%) — a real concern given how prevalent it is
Even the 10th-worst matchup (Boros Energy) is a large sample at 225 matches and still unfavorable
Overall, Broodscale sits at ~52.9% overall WR, so these matchups represent notable drags on its performance

Sources: Data from 166 Modern tournaments (Jul 15–Sep 14, 2026) — 65.7% MTGO, 34.3% Melee