I'll analyze the matchup spread for Temur Otters in Modern. Let me start by getting an overview of the archetype and then look at its performance against other top decks.
I see that Temur Otters is actually a Standard archetype, not Modern. Let me get the correct matchup data for Standard format:
Now let me get the matchup data for Temur Otters against the top Standard archetypes:
Based on 57 tournament entries over the last 60 days, here's how Temur Otters (50.6% overall winrate) performs against the top Standard archetypes:
Favorable Matchups:
• vs Reanimator: 75.0% (6-2) - Excellent matchup
• vs Simic Midrange: 61.5% (8-5) - Strong advantage
• vs Dimir Midrange: 56.3% (18-14) - Solid edge
Even Matchups:
• vs Mono Red Aggro: 54.5% (6-5) - Slightly favored
• vs Jeskai Control: 52.6% (10-9) - Nearly even
Problematic Matchups:
• vs Izzet Cauldron: No recorded matches (Cauldron dominates the meta at 18.5% presence with 56.1% winrate)
Key Takeaway: Temur Otters appears strong against midrange decks and has an excellent Reanimator matchup, but lacks data against the format's top deck (Izzet Cauldron). The archetype sits at a modest tier with balanced matchups across most of the field.
Sources:
Data from 25 tournaments (64% MTGO, 36% Melee). Recent examples: EUL Standard National, MTGO Standard Challenge 12/6